UnofficialCommunity-compiledVanilla

Part of: Idle Guild Master: Doctrines, Traits & Early Dungeons — doctrine defaults, traits, and early dungeon progression.

Idle Guild Master Aegis: How Many to Buy, Rebuying, and Aegis vs Living Whip or Scarlet Veil

Player question: How many Aegis swords should you buy in vanilla Idle Guild Master, can you buy Aegis again from the shop, and should you choose a second Aegis over Scarlet Veil, Living Whip, or gem armor?

I like these games and play them myself. Complete guides are hard to find online, so while playing I collect community experience from Reddit, add a little of my own notes, and put this site together—hoping it helps. Thank you.

Quick answer

Recommendation Default: buy one Aegis for your main tank.[1][2] Buy Scarlet Veil next.[3][1]

Recommendation Buy a second Aegis only when raids need a second tank to take hits that one-shot everyone else.[1][2] Living Whip can cover the second tank’s taunt if you keep to one Aegis.[2][1]

How many Aegis to buy

Recommendation Default: one Aegis on the main tank. One Aegis is sufficient for regular progression, giving your primary frontline unit the durability needed to hold threat.[1][2]

Recommendation Buy a second Aegis only when end-game raids require an off-tank to absorb massive hits that take down the rest of the party.[1][2]

Community Knowledge Purchasing past two or three Aegis is rarely needed.[1] Raids rarely call for three tanks.[1]

Can you buy Aegis again?

Observed Game Fact Aegis is not a single-time purchase. The item can reappear for purchase after you already own one Aegis.[2]

Community Knowledge Seeing another Aegis appear in the rotating shop depends on luck.[2] If you plan to equip a second Aegis for raids, keep resources ready for when the shop offers it again.[2]

Second Aegis vs Scarlet Veil vs Living Whip

Recommendation Default: craft Scarlet Veil before buying a second Aegis. Put Scarlet Strands toward the veil first, then decide whether raids still need a second Aegis.[3][1]

Community Knowledge The primary value of Aegis lies in health and defensive bonuses rather than the taunt alone. Tanks rely heavily on defensive stats and survivability to endure incoming damage.[1]

Recommendation Living Whip covers off-tank taunting only when you choose to keep to one Aegis.[2] Living Whip arrives later in dungeon progression and can supply the needed taunt effect for an off-tank without purchasing another Aegis.[1][2]

Community Knowledge Living Whip trade-offs: while the whip provides a taunt, it lacks the health and defensive bonuses of Aegis.[1]

Aegis or the gem armor first

Recommendation Default: buy the Aegis sword before the gem armor.[4]

Scope & limits

Version-sensitive This guide covers vanilla Idle Guild Master only. Content, characters, and items from the community expansion mod are excluded.

Community Knowledge Findings reflect community discussions on r/IdleGuildMaster regarding tank gearing choices and shop rotations. Game updates can alter item availability, shop mechanics, or combat balance across versions.

Community sources

  1. How many Aegis do you really need? (opens Reddit)

    u/Randonaut3: “Aegis solo necesitas 1.” [Aegis you only need 1.] — comment p6yduzg

    u/Educational-Fun3513: “Every tank gets one.” — comment p6yk81f

    u/AkihoshiSenpai: “Most end game raids require two just to tank massive hits that will one shot everything else.” — comment p6z0eli

    u/AkihoshiSenpai: “The most important feature of Aegis is the defense buffs, the Taunt is a nice to have.” — comment p6z0eli

    u/Fomor666: “raids rarely have three tanks, and in endgame dungeons, an Aegis is practically unnecessary.” — comment p6ylc7r

    u/Fomor666: “Besides, the aegis has quite useful bonuses to HP and defense.” — comment p6ylpbk

    u/SnooDogs5242: “by the time you can use whip, you either have aegis or your tank is already Taunting.” — comment p74wvon

  2. Is Aegis a one time buy now? (opens Reddit)

    u/KnotFound1994: “Um é suficiente” [One is enough] — comment pe46nsl

    u/OG_Rokoma: “1 tank and 1 offtank in raids. You can supplement for the living whip i suppose if you only want 1.” — comment pe578jp

    u/CalligrapherOther532: “Yesss I have one and I can buy another is just luck” — comment pe2s2pt

    u/Soul82: “Had 2 so far.” — comment pf1zi8n

    u/ion_driver: “I bought 2.” — comment pe2rze8

  3. 2nd aegis for divine duelist (opens Reddit)

    u/jardfred: “You should buy a scarlet veil before your second aegis” — comment ojjw66c

  4. Do i buy this first or Aegis sword? (opens Reddit)

    u/Educational-Fun3513: “Aegis first” — comment oxgd13g

    u/Dry_Category3955: “Normally you buy the sword first as far as I know” — comment oxfzsp9

    u/Kitchen-Helicopter72: “I did the sword and I think it was the correct call.” — comment oxodur2

Evidence via Arctic Shift; ids re-checked this run. Edition: vanilla.