MiniMeta

UnofficialRelated guideCommunity-compiled

Part of: Idle Guild Master: Doctrines, Traits & Early Dungeons — doctrine defaults, traits, and early dungeon notes.

Idle Guild Master: Tank Leveling & Tank Doctrines — What Players Say

Players on r/IdleGuildMaster describe how they level a tank and which doctrine a tank should take, and they disagree about the Paladin. This page puts their comments side by side, with dates and a link to each quoted comment, and keeps three eras apart. It is a sample of one community, not a verified guide.

I like these games and play them myself. Complete guides are hard to find online, so while playing I collect community experience from Reddit and put this site together—hoping it helps. Thank you.

Quick answer

Community Knowledge u/apekillape (2025-06-24, era B, comment mzgm9ya) answered the question “Fastest way to level a Tank?”: Fastest though would probably be a duo with a Rider in D2.[1] The cited players then name other places and XP-per-hour figures, recommend different doctrines for tanks, and disagree about the Paladin (see Where players disagree). This page does not say whether a Paladin is a tank: it shows the comments side by side in its own section. Counted by script (see Counts), “tank”, “танк” or “Titan” is mentioned in 2363 comments by 397 authors and “Paladin” in 508 comments by 140 authors; a mention is not an endorsement.

Scope, eras & game versions

This page covers only what named players wrote about leveling a tank, doctrines for tanks and the Paladin in Guild Master - Idle Dungeons (community name: Idle Guild Master). It uses a topic-selected re-collection of r/IdleGuildMaster (3908 threads: 3901 from r/IdleGuildMaster and 7 from r/incremental_games; 25233 comments), collected via the Arctic Shift archive on 2026-10-04; threads without the selection keywords may be missing. Every quote is matched against that collection by an automated test, line breaks included; author, date and score come from the collection. Nothing here was checked in the game. Class names are the commenters’ own words.

The game changes, so every date carries an era:

  • Era A: up to 2025-05-15. The collection holds no comment dated before 2025-05-16 that contains a doctrine word (doctrin- or доктрин-; checked by the page test), so doctrine statements start in era B.
  • Era B: 2025-05-16 to 2025-09-25. Developer version notes exist in the collection for this period.
  • Era C: from 2025-09-26. The newest version note in the collection is version 2.134 (2025-09-25), so era C comments carry no game version.

Version-sensitive u/Paranoid-Squirrels (2025-01-05, era A, post 1hu1uo2) wrote: Experience balance: Several enemies experience have been adjusted: i will list changes per area, and not individual enemy, for simplicity.[2] Because experience per area was adjusted on 2025-01-05, this page does not compare XP-per-hour figures dated before that day with later ones.

Labels: Community Knowledge what a named player wrote; Version-sensitive a version-note line tied to a date. Non-English quotes are given in the original with a literal English translation labelled “(translation by MiniMeta, not verified by the author)”. Where the collection has no statement, this page writes “limited sample”.

Counts

Community Knowledge Script-computed mention counts; a name is “mentioned” when it appears in a comment of the scope, including dismissive or negative mentions. Scope 1: the 2363 comments (in 1302 threads, by 397 authors) that contain “tank”, “танк” or “Titan”. Scope 2: the 122 of those comments dated 2025-05-16 or later whose own text or thread title contains “doctrin” (in 91 threads, by 48 authors). Scope 3: the 508 comments (in 337 threads, by 140 authors) that contain “Paladin” or “паладин”.

Names in scope 1 (mentions, not recommendations)
NameCommentsAuthorsEra AEra BEra C
Titan69416343880176
Kings Hand1033877620
Paladin21673942993
Dark Knight8638441032
Fortress52305443
Aegis3089614515148
Doctrine names in scope 2 (era B and C only)
DoctrineCommentsAuthorsEra BEra C
Fortitude2015713
Control27151017
Grace2813622
Ruin1716512
War2313419
Affliction13849
Illusion2616719
Knowledge1812612
Words in scope 3, the Paladin comments
WordCommentsAuthorsEra AEra BEra C
tank (any form)14754491880
Titan11043662222
darkness18773891979
Larox84008
Fortitude66006

Reproduce with python3 research/pipeline/jobs/idle-guild-master/page_build/tank_leveling_doctrines.py --counts (from the repository root). The counts are neither exact nor a ceiling: ordinary words (control, war, grace, ruin, titan, dark) and spelling variants change the result, and comments quoted on this page may fall outside a scope. They say how often a name was mentioned, not what works.

Where players disagree

Each table puts comments side by side with author, date, era and comment link (the link goes to the permalink table under Sources).

Where to level a tank, and the XP per hour written

Seven threads; comments dated 2024-08-08 to 2026-09-14. The figures are as written and are not comparable: the set-ups differ (solo, duo, team), mzoxzww and p3lhreg give a total and a per-unit figure, and the eras differ; era A is dated before the 2025-01-05 experience change. In p3lhreg, per the quote, the 31k figure is for the character being leveled, not for the tank; u/Fomor666 (2026-08-14, era C, comment p3lrmv1) wrote in the same thread: it's more of a team for leveling up other classes[3]. u/Rinkanokirin (2026-08-14, era C, comment p3luv22) gives the 50-60k figure for “alts”, which are the characters being leveled. mzgz8ks, mzoxzww and mzs29hz answer the same question in the thread “Fastest way to level a Tank?”
Era A (2024-08)Era B (2025-06 to 2025-08)Era C (2026-08 to 2026-09)

u/Fluffy-Internet-6250, 2024-08-08, era A, comment lh35t52:
So far, the Kings Hand can solo both D4 and D5, but he is unmatched for D5 (he is making 9-9.5k xp/h).[4]

u/ForsakenHeight4798, 2025-06-24, era B, comment mzgz8ks:
If solo d5 with champions armor + amulet swordman + counter attack pets. 11k exp/h.


Without solo only d2/d3 with exp armor + exp accessories sames 11k exp/h[1]

u/jrohrer13, 2025-06-25, era B, comment mzoxzww:
I'm leveling my tanks duo in d7 with ascended night rogue. 50k~ an hour so 25k to each.[1]

u/AshtonShiken, 2025-06-25, era B, comment mzs29hz:
Duo D7 with a night lament is likely going to beat any other option at the point you are at, unless you are going the divine champion route.[1]

u/benk1102, 2025-07-31, era B, comment n63m08s:
Tanks can solo d3 (with R4 drops) and D5 (with doctrines) I've been getting about 18k xp/h in each which bears what I can get my healers.[5]

u/ForsakenHeight4798, 2025-08-15, era B, comment n8su0fm:
Titan line. With Doctrine fortitude solo in golden city 20-22k exp/h[6]

u/Born-Armadillo-4139, 2025-08-31, era B, comment nbn2tyu:
I'm duoing with NL using Grace and Aegis/Sage Armor/Diamond Amulet. Juggernaut is doing about 38000xp/h.[7]

u/Fomor666, 2026-08-14, era C, comment p3lhreg:
I use a rogue and tank combo to quickly level other characters in D7, averaging around 60k experience per hour (the tank and rogue get 100%, the character being leveled gets 215%, meaning they get 31k experience per hour).[3]

u/Rinkanokirin, 2026-08-14, era C, comment p3luv22:
2 celestial rain get near 30% of this exp (it useless) so pure exp for alts 50-60k exp/hour.[3]

u/BigT10116878, 2026-09-14, era C, comment p9quzcd:
That bad Titan + spike lead farm on D3 get 18k exp ~ 9k exp per hour on 1 mem[8]

Titan right away, or another class first?

Two threads; comments dated 2025-08-07 to 2026-03-03. Not a flat contradiction: o8fru3z also ends on Titan. o8do2wg and o8fru3z answer the same thread
Another class first, Titan after ascensionTitan

u/DeadPhish, 2025-08-07, era B, comment n7dno4j:
Keep the royal as is and let him solo farm pirates ubtil ascension and swap him to titan after ascension.
Titan is painfully slow to lvl otherwise.[9]

u/NullIsNotEmpty, 2026-03-03, era C, comment o8fru3z:
The best is a titan. But if you want the big pic, first make him a kings hand, because it is the best class to lvl up. After ascension make it a titan.[10]

u/Educational-Fun3513, 2026-03-03, era C, comment o8do2wg:
Titan[10]

Which doctrine for a tank?

Six threads; comments dated 2025-05-17 to 2026-08-27. Era B and era C are mixed in each column; read the date label in each cell. nbn7ql7, nbmott3 and nbndc7k are in one thread dated 2025-08-31. In p4ad868 the words “champion” and “fortress” are the commenter’s class names; p64uz86 writes “Fortress Doctrine” and does not say which doctrine it means
FortitudeControlOthers (Grace, War, Affliction), and one unclear

u/Key-Speed-2688, 2025-05-17, era B, comment mssf122:
Tanks go Fortitude, War would have been possible but ParanoidSquirrels nerfed the serpent dagger preemptively[11]

u/-Traffej-, 2025-08-31, era B, comment nbn7ql7:
Fortitude is overall the best for all aspects.[7]

u/Educational-Fun3513, 2026-08-26, era C, comment p62pgd8:
Fortitude for tanks. Grace also kinda works.[12]

u/nevercontribute1, 2026-03-09, era C, post 1rp7u7i:
Am I missing something about Fortitude? It looks extremely underwhelming for tanks other than the +1 threat.[13]

u/-Traffej-, 2025-08-31, era B, comment nbn7ql7:
Some are using control, but it is a pure bullsht[7]

u/ForsakenHeight4798, 2025-08-31, era B, comment nbndc7k:
So control doctrine + morningstars more profits for new raid[7]

u/ForsakenHeight4798, 2025-08-31, era B, comment nbmott3:
For better tank and if want solo with serpen bite - fortitude. If want lvl with nl or 3 archers - grace. For new raid - control[7]

u/Fomor666, 2026-08-17, era C, comment p4ad868:
If you're choosing a champion, the best choice would be Doctrine of War. If you're choosing a fortress, considering the traits, I'd recommend either Doctrine of Fortitude or Affliction.[14]

u/HenryW01F, 2026-08-27, era C, comment p64uz86:
If you're focusing on a character to tank all the damage, Fortress Doctrine, my man.[15]

Which doctrine while leveling?

Two threads; comments dated 2025-08-31 to 2025-12-09. nbmrs1u is a reply to nbmq88a; nt1akji is from a different thread and era and does not answer them
Ruin in D1Fortitude in D3, or next to a Night Lament in D7War until max level, then switch

u/DeadPhish, 2025-08-31, era B, comment nbmq88a:
For solo lvling in D1, go with ruin for extra hits.[7]

u/Key-Speed-2688, 2025-08-31, era B, comment nbmrs1u:
But why D1
why not D3 with fortitude and Magic Thorns damage
or just put him next to a Night Lament in D7

it's so much faster even if you had to train a new shadow rogue[7]

u/Alauzhen, 2025-12-09, era C, comment nt1akji:
You can switch doctrines for 50 diamonds, one way to speed things up is to put war doctrine to get max level on an ascended character then switch it to your desired doctrine at max level.[16]

The Paladin: a dispute

Community Knowledge Whether a Paladin is a tank is disputed in the collection. This page does not say that a Paladin is a tank and does not say that it is not one; it shows who wrote what and when. No consensus is claimed, and the developer items below do not settle it.

One exchange, September 2026

One thread; comments dated 2026-09-19 to 2026-09-21. All four comments are in the thread “Best doctrine for paladin?”. pb4x74b replies to pat3xhf, pb4zvka replies to pb4x74b, and pb567fk replies to pb4zvka. Within a column the comments are in date order
u/Mean_Set_8300u/ElephantIcy460

u/Mean_Set_8300, 2026-09-19, era C, comment pat3xhf:
Паладин не танк. Ему не нужна доктрина стойкости. “Paladin is not a tank. He does not need the doctrine of fortitude.” (translation by MiniMeta, not verified by the author)[17]

u/Mean_Set_8300, 2026-09-21, era C, comment pb4zvka:
К сожалению в ларкосе он только и полезен банально из-за сопротивления статусам, которое можно на зельях до сотки дотянуть. В потерянных землях он даже вреден из-за ритуала. “Unfortunately, in Larkos he is only useful, simply, because of the resistance to statuses, which can be pulled up to a hundred with potions. In the Lost Lands he is even harmful because of the ritual.” (translation by MiniMeta, not verified by the author)[17]

u/ElephantIcy460, 2026-09-21, era C, comment pb4x74b:
Как танк он недооценён, но максимум в трех локациях, две из которых рейды, а в одном из которых он полезен просто из за снижения тьмы. Если юзать его как танка то только для ларокса, а доктрина стойкости даст ему комфортную выживаемость. “As a tank he is underrated, but at most in three locations, two of which are raids, and in one of which he is useful simply because of the reduction of darkness. If you use him as a tank, then only for Larox, and the doctrine of fortitude will give him comfortable survivability.” (translation by MiniMeta, not verified by the author)[17]

u/ElephantIcy460, 2026-09-21, era C, comment pb567fk:
Паладин магический танк созданный для узконаправленной работы “Paladin is a magical tank created for narrowly focused work.” (translation by MiniMeta, not verified by the author)[17]

Other comments, by era

Eleven threads; comments dated 2024-08-07 to 2026-08-25. This is a selection, not every such comment: the quoted comments are ones that say in their own words how a Paladin does as a tank, found by reading the Paladin comments; the collection holds more (see Counts). The columns sort the comments by what each says, not by correctness. lgwo20i, lmcpdob, lmor0zv and lng7phm are dated before 2025-03-01, the day of the developer item below that lowers the Paladin branch’s magic defense; no comment here is a test result
Says a Paladin is useless, or a poor or niche tankSays a Paladin can tank, at least in some content

u/topshelf821, 2024-09-09, era A, comment lmcpdob:
For me personally, I don't like paladins and dark knights. I think kings hand and titan are much better tanks.[18]

u/topshelf821, 2024-09-11, era A, comment lmor0zv:
Keep him if you want, but I'm not a fan of dark knights or paladins. Their abilities are too niche and I think they're sub par tanks due to having the lowest threat.[19]

u/-Traffej-, 2025-05-26, era B, comment mue007n:
And I really recommend you to get rid of paladins, you may keep one, however I still consider them as totally useless.[20]

u/Educational-Fun3513, 2026-04-27, era C, comment oijcwuz:
The only real tank is fortress. Paladin and dark knight have only niche uses and duelist is a solo class[21]

u/Rinkanokirin, 2026-08-25, era C, comment p5tdds8:
Танки только титаны. Королевская стража/дк/паладины - чисто поразвлекаться если скучно. “Tanks are only titans. Royal guard/dk/paladins - purely to have fun if bored.” (translation by MiniMeta, not verified by the author)[22]

u/Sneralted, 2024-08-07, era A, comment lgwo20i:
He's arguably the best tank to use while farming D7 for XP (his darkness reduction helps a ton for preventing wipes)[23]

u/Fluffy-Internet-6250, 2024-09-16, era A, comment lng7phm:
Hmm generally the best is the titan (Iron Guard path), but Paladin is solid too (more biaised towards Magic tank).[24]

u/unofficialSperm, 2025-06-27, era B, comment n00h1ih:
And these Dungeons were a Big difficulty Spike and you actually needed a Titan as a Tank(Up to d7 its perfectly doable with a Paladin as a Tank, Titan was Just better at it).[25]

u/insignificant-kid, 2026-03-09, era C, comment o9ex2u3:
They are incredibly good at eliminating darkness and can be a serviceable tank.[26]

u/Fomor666, 2026-05-04, era C, comment ojsjy8m:
Each class has its own purpose, paladins are not damage dealers, they are more of an anti-magic tank.[27]

u/More_Independence_43, 2026-05-12, era C, comment olgk7zz:
But FYI if you include doctrines and late game gear, Mr Paladin becomes a really solid option for a Anti Mage Tank.[28]

Developer items that name the Paladin

Script check: the collection holds 44 posts and 121 comments by u/Paranoid-Squirrels; 4 of the posts and 1 of the comments contain “Paladin”. They are quoted here in date order.

  • Community Knowledge u/Paranoid-Squirrels (2024-06-17, era A, comment l8zs6bq) asked: Did you send a previous team before, and sent the paladin without collecting the drops?[29]
  • Version-sensitive u/Paranoid-Squirrels (2024-08-15, era A, post 1est32l) wrote: Paladin passive: darkness reduction treated as flat, and not percentage (no changes to actual mechanic)[30]
  • Version-sensitive u/Paranoid-Squirrels (2025-01-23, era A, post 1i811m3) wrote: Instill Terror (active ability of Bleak Disciple): now, stun roll is made before the execution, applying the status even if the ability is dodged (similarly to the Paladin's line SILENCE).[31]
  • Version-sensitive u/Paranoid-Squirrels (2025-02-01, era A, post 1if2qvu) wrote: while the paladins are very effective for the new raid, it shouldn't be the only option[32]
  • Version-sensitive u/Paranoid-Squirrels (2025-03-01, era A, post 1j11l7o) wrote: Paladin branch: magic defense growth progression reduced across all ranks, in such a way that T9: 50 -> 40[33] u/Paranoid-Squirrels (2025-03-01, era A, post 1j11l7o) wrote in the same post: Titan branch: defense and magic defense growth progression reduced across all ranks, in such a way that T9: 35 -> 30[33] u/Paranoid-Squirrels (2025-03-01, era A, post 1j11l7o) wrote under NOTES in the same post: About the reduction in def/mDef in the tank classes: in order to deal enough damage to the tanks to out-heal the healers, the damage of enemies had to be high enough to always oneshot everyone else (Angel of War could reach a mDef of 90!).[33]

Of these items, only the post 1j11l7o contains the word “tank”; it names the Paladin branch and the Titan branch in its balance list and writes “the tank classes” in its notes, but it does not say which classes it means by that, and this page draws no conclusion from it. No developer item in the collection says in so many words that the Paladin is, or is not, a tank.

Single statements

Statements shown without a side-by-side partner (limited sample):

  • Community Knowledge A way to level a Titan build (era C): u/Fomor666 (2026-09-14, era C, comment p9s3u4o) writes: Alternatively, you can level this Titan build (swapping the amulet for a Crown) while teamed up with a Rogue in D7—that’s another way to gain a lot of XP.[8]

What this page cannot tell you

  • The XP-per-hour figures are what the named players wrote, in different units and set-ups; this page did not check them.
  • The 20 quoted era C comments come from 11 authors; u/Fomor666 wrote 5 of them. They are not independent votes.
  • Era C carries no game version; if the game changed after 2025-09-25, some newer statements may no longer apply.
  • The collection has no developer statement that settles which doctrine suits a tank or whether the Paladin is a tank.
  • This page has no recommendation of its own. It lists who said what and when.

Sources & evidence

33 real r/IdleGuildMaster threads from the Arctic Shift collection (numbers [1]–[33] match the footnotes). Non-English titles carry a translation labelled “translation by MiniMeta, not verified by the author”.

  1. Fastest way to level a Tank? (opens Reddit) — started by u/MrZev2 on 2025-06-24; quoted: u/AshtonShiken, u/ForsakenHeight4798, u/apekillape, u/jrohrer13 (4 items).
  2. Version 2.72 notes (thread by u/Paranoid-Squirrels, 2025-01-05) (opens Reddit) — started by u/Paranoid-Squirrels on 2025-01-05; quoted: u/Paranoid-Squirrels (1 item).
  3. Any faster way of getting xp (opens Reddit) — started by u/Dry_Category3955 on 2026-08-13; quoted: u/Fomor666, u/Rinkanokirin (3 items).
  4. solo dungeon (opens Reddit) — started by u/ProperAnimal000 on 2024-08-08; quoted: u/Fluffy-Internet-6250 (1 item).
  5. Void pendent or Void armor? (opens Reddit) — started by u/Remarkable_Fly7028 on 2025-07-30; quoted: u/benk1102 (1 item).
  6. Tank (opens Reddit) — started by u/Nicotino_ on 2025-08-15; quoted: u/ForsakenHeight4798 (1 item).
  7. which doctrine? (opens Reddit) — started by u/Born-Armadillo-4139 on 2025-08-31; quoted: u/-Traffej-, u/Born-Armadillo-4139, u/DeadPhish, u/ForsakenHeight4798, u/Key-Speed-2688 (6 items).
  8. Any trick to tank fast gain exp (opens Reddit) — started by u/BigT10116878 on 2026-09-14; quoted: u/BigT10116878, u/Fomor666 (2 items).
  9. Need some opinion (opens Reddit) — started by u/Nice_Maintenance960 on 2025-08-07; quoted: u/DeadPhish (1 item).
  10. Tank (opens Reddit) — started by u/ElectronicAd4982 on 2026-03-03; quoted: u/Educational-Fun3513, u/NullIsNotEmpty (2 items).
  11. Doctrines and meta (opens Reddit) — started by u/DeadPhish on 2025-05-17; quoted: u/Key-Speed-2688 (1 item).
  12. Pls acenssion (opens Reddit) — started by u/Euphoric-Secret2360 on 2026-08-24; quoted: u/Educational-Fun3513 (1 item).
  13. Doctrine of Affliction for tank? (opens Reddit) — started by u/nevercontribute1 on 2026-03-09; quoted: u/nevercontribute1 (1 item).
  14. Doctrine help (opens Reddit) — started by u/Leading-Grapefruit56 on 2026-08-17; quoted: u/Fomor666 (1 item).
  15. Best doctrine for a tank? (opens Reddit) — started by u/Halfsack89 on 2026-08-26; quoted: u/HenryW01F (1 item).
  16. Mottiphobia observations (opens Reddit) — started by u/Alauzhen on 2025-12-08; quoted: u/Alauzhen (1 item).
  17. Best doctrine for paladin? (opens Reddit) — started by u/Kindly_Incident5892 on 2026-09-18; quoted: u/ElephantIcy460, u/Mean_Set_8300 (4 items).
  18. Did I at least somewhat get a good mix of classes or should I redo some (besides no traits) (opens Reddit) — started by u/EnGa_Management on 2024-09-09; quoted: u/topshelf821 (1 item).
  19. I need help (opens Reddit) — started by u/Frequent-Back4059 on 2024-09-11; quoted: u/topshelf821 (1 item).
  20. Frostbite Peak difficulty (opens Reddit) — started by u/Unlucky-Match-6363 on 2025-05-26; quoted: u/-Traffej- (1 item).
  21. Two questions (opens Reddit) — started by u/citizenofusa1776 on 2026-04-27; quoted: u/Educational-Fun3513 (1 item).
  22. Нужны советы по прокачке (opens Reddit) — started by u/urchin_Gora on 2026-08-25; quoted: u/Rinkanokirin (1 item).
  23. Could you give me some advice? Adventurers, equipment collocation or farm. (opens Reddit) — started by u/captain_luo on 2024-08-07; quoted: u/Sneralted (1 item).
  24. How about this one? (opens Reddit) — started by u/Any-Bullfrog5306 on 2024-09-16; quoted: u/Fluffy-Internet-6250 (1 item).
  25. D7 help (opens Reddit) — started by u/vsm994 on 2025-06-27; quoted: u/unofficialSperm (1 item).
  26. Early Game Party Guidance (opens Reddit) — started by u/OG_Rokoma on 2026-03-08; quoted: u/insignificant-kid (1 item).
  27. Ayuda y opinión (opens Reddit) — started by u/Capable_Put_7086 on 2026-05-03; quoted: u/Fomor666 (1 item).
  28. Evolution doubts (opens Reddit) — started by u/Zylvorak on 2026-05-12; quoted: u/More_Independence_43 (1 item).
  29. How is this possible? (opens Reddit) — started by u/Murky-Diamond-945 on 2024-06-16; quoted: u/Paranoid-Squirrels (1 item).
  30. Version 2.25 notes (thread by u/Paranoid-Squirrels, 2024-08-15) (opens Reddit) — started by u/Paranoid-Squirrels on 2024-08-15; quoted: u/Paranoid-Squirrels (1 item).
  31. Version 2.75 notes (thread by u/Paranoid-Squirrels, 2025-01-23) (opens Reddit) — started by u/Paranoid-Squirrels on 2025-01-23; quoted: u/Paranoid-Squirrels (1 item).
  32. Version 2.80 notes (thread by u/Paranoid-Squirrels, 2025-02-01) (opens Reddit) — started by u/Paranoid-Squirrels on 2025-02-01; quoted: u/Paranoid-Squirrels (1 item).
  33. Version 2.82 notes (thread by u/Paranoid-Squirrels, 2025-03-01) (opens Reddit) — started by u/Paranoid-Squirrels on 2025-03-01; quoted: u/Paranoid-Squirrels (1 item).

One row per quoted comment or post: id, author, time of posting, score stored in the collection and the Reddit permalink. Scores are small numbers and are not evidence of correctness.

Permalinks of every quote on this page
IdTypeAuthorPostedScoreThreadPermalink
mzgm9yacommentu/apekillape2025-06-24 05:00 UTC2[1]mzgm9ya
1hu1uo2postu/Paranoid-Squirrels2025-01-05 08:34 UTC29[2]1hu1uo2
p3lrmv1commentu/Fomor6662026-08-14 07:43 UTC1[3]p3lrmv1
p3luv22commentu/Rinkanokirin2026-08-14 08:10 UTC2[3]p3luv22
lh35t52commentu/Fluffy-Internet-62502024-08-08 10:50 UTC4[4]lh35t52
mzgz8kscommentu/ForsakenHeight47982025-06-24 06:54 UTC4[1]mzgz8ks
mzoxzwwcommentu/jrohrer132025-06-25 13:18 UTC2[1]mzoxzww
mzs29hzcommentu/AshtonShiken2025-06-25 22:15 UTC2[1]mzs29hz
n63m08scommentu/benk11022025-07-31 03:05 UTC2[5]n63m08s
n8su0fmcommentu/ForsakenHeight47982025-08-15 08:57 UTC1[6]n8su0fm
nbn2tyucommentu/Born-Armadillo-41392025-08-31 10:33 UTC2[7]nbn2tyu
p3lhregcommentu/Fomor6662026-08-14 06:23 UTC3[3]p3lhreg
p9quzcdcommentu/BigT101168782026-09-14 13:05 UTC1[8]p9quzcd
n7dno4jcommentu/DeadPhish2025-08-07 07:44 UTC2[9]n7dno4j
o8fru3zcommentu/NullIsNotEmpty2026-03-03 16:52 UTC3[10]o8fru3z
o8do2wgcommentu/Educational-Fun35132026-03-03 08:32 UTC3[10]o8do2wg
mssf122commentu/Key-Speed-26882025-05-17 13:17 UTC2[11]mssf122
nbn7ql7commentu/-Traffej-2025-08-31 11:16 UTC2[7]nbn7ql7
p62pgd8commentu/Educational-Fun35132026-08-26 19:55 UTC1[12]p62pgd8
1rp7u7ipostu/nevercontribute12026-03-09 18:10 UTC2[13]1rp7u7i
nbndc7kcommentu/ForsakenHeight47982025-08-31 12:00 UTC1[7]nbndc7k
nbmott3commentu/ForsakenHeight47982025-08-31 08:15 UTC2[7]nbmott3
p4ad868commentu/Fomor6662026-08-17 20:19 UTC2[14]p4ad868
p64uz86commentu/HenryW01F2026-08-27 02:20 UTC1[15]p64uz86
nbmq88acommentu/DeadPhish2025-08-31 08:29 UTC1[7]nbmq88a
nbmrs1ucommentu/Key-Speed-26882025-08-31 08:44 UTC2[7]nbmrs1u
nt1akjicommentu/Alauzhen2025-12-09 01:07 UTC2[16]nt1akji
pat3xhfcommentu/Mean_Set_83002026-09-19 17:54 UTC1[17]pat3xhf
pb4zvkacommentu/Mean_Set_83002026-09-21 10:50 UTC1[17]pb4zvka
pb4x74bcommentu/ElephantIcy4602026-09-21 10:30 UTC1[17]pb4x74b
pb567fkcommentu/ElephantIcy4602026-09-21 11:32 UTC1[17]pb567fk
lmcpdobcommentu/topshelf8212024-09-09 22:55 UTC3[18]lmcpdob
lmor0zvcommentu/topshelf8212024-09-11 23:44 UTC2[19]lmor0zv
mue007ncommentu/-Traffej-2025-05-26 18:57 UTC1[20]mue007n
oijcwuzcommentu/Educational-Fun35132026-04-27 11:15 UTC1[21]oijcwuz
p5tdds8commentu/Rinkanokirin2026-08-25 15:02 UTC4[22]p5tdds8
lgwo20icommentu/Sneralted2024-08-07 08:03 UTC6[23]lgwo20i
lng7phmcommentu/Fluffy-Internet-62502024-09-16 18:43 UTC2[24]lng7phm
n00h1ihcommentu/unofficialSperm2025-06-27 04:52 UTC2[25]n00h1ih
o9ex2u3commentu/insignificant-kid2026-03-09 01:17 UTC2[26]o9ex2u3
ojsjy8mcommentu/Fomor6662026-05-04 02:08 UTC2[27]ojsjy8m
olgk7zzcommentu/More_Independence_432026-05-12 22:30 UTC5[28]olgk7zz
l8zs6bqcommentu/Paranoid-Squirrels2024-06-17 12:50 UTC1[29]l8zs6bq
1est32lpostu/Paranoid-Squirrels2024-08-15 11:47 UTC30[30]1est32l
1i811m3postu/Paranoid-Squirrels2025-01-23 11:11 UTC19[31]1i811m3
1if2qvupostu/Paranoid-Squirrels2025-02-01 09:25 UTC26[32]1if2qvu
1j11l7opostu/Paranoid-Squirrels2025-03-01 15:12 UTC17[33]1j11l7o
p9s3u4ocommentu/Fomor6662026-09-14 16:25 UTC1[8]p9s3u4o

Evidence via Evidence Job pointer under research/pipeline/jobs/idle-guild-master/ (full re-collection corpus, Refs #111). Claim classes defined on this site: Observed Game Fact, Community Knowledge, Recommendation, Version-sensitive. Used on this page: Community Knowledge, Version-sensitive.

Credits

Primary sources: player posts and comments on r/IdleGuildMaster. This page organizes that experience; it does not claim authorship of community knowledge.

This site is unofficial and not affiliated with the developer.